Warsaw: The problem of censorship in social media. The debate organized by the Ordo Iuris Institute


Home   >   News

Warsaw: The problem of censorship in social media. The debate organized by the Ordo Iuris Institute

Many Internet users face the problem of censorship in social media. The debate organized on 17th September by the Ordo Iuris Institute as part of the HDIM 2019 conference in Warsaw was devoted to this issue. Lawyers and journalists from Poland and abroad took part in the event.

 

During the meeting, journalists - Jolanta Hajdasz Ph. D. (Association of Polish Journalists), Paweł Lisicki ("Do Rzeczy", wSensie.tv), Cezary Krysztopa ("Tygodnik Solidarność"), Krzysztof Łuksza (wRealu24.pl), Łukasz Karpiel (PCh24.pl), and Varro Vooglaid - lawyer and publicist from Estonia. During the event, attention was drawn to the fact that contemporary censorship on social networks is also increasingly taking an economic dimension. In addition to simple blocking or removal of content, administrators of social platforms are also going to reduce monetization, i.e. turning off the possibility of earning money on materials considered "substandard".

 

The speakers also emphasized that almost only conservative content was censored. Platform administrators often use the imprecise term 'hate speech'. In many cases, Internet users are also not informed about the reasons why the materials they posted have been removed.

The debate was opened by attonrey Jerzy Kwasniewski.

 

"Freedom of speech and freedom of assembly are fundamental freedoms of democratic societies. They guarantee the proper process legitimizing the system, legitimizing public power and exercising it, ”emphasized President of Ordo Iuris.

 

The censorship mechanism used by the owners of Facebook and YouTube portals was described by Tymoteusz Zych Ph. D., Vice President of the Ordo Iuris Institute. He also presented postulates for introducing appropriate legal changes to guarantee freedom of speech on social networks.

"Access to information is determined by social media. Undoubtedly, this sphere needs legal regulations "- noted Dr. Zych.

 

Attorney Tomasz Piotr Chudzinski, in turn, discussed current legal response tools for unjustified removal of content posted on social media platforms.

 

"In Poland, the right to freely express one's views is considered as a personal good. If there is censorship in social media, there is a violation of the personal good of the user who posted certain content", he said.

 

The debate was part of the Human Dimension Implementation Meeting - the annual largest conference on human rights and democracy in Europe. Every year, representatives of Ordo Iuris take part in it.

 

Jolanta Hajdasz Ph. D. drew attention to what content is most often affected by censorship.

„What connects cases of censored content on social media is, above all, their right-wing, conservative nature. We have dozens of cases of suspending various types of profiles, or disabling their ability to earn, limitting ranges, etc.” she said.

 

Paweł Lisicki pointed to the vagueness of the concept of "hate speech".

 

„We will never be able to define the concept of "hate speech". We would have to determine the scale of the feeling. This is a task for a psychologist rather than a lawyer.” he claimed.

 

"Operation of independent television outside YouTube is practically impossible at the moment. We can said that YouTube is a monopolist, "noted Krzysztof Łuksza.

 

Łukasz Karpiel talked about how the activities of the administration of social networks affect Catholics.

 

„Hatred against Catholics has an impact on the internet. Facebook removes conservative content and turns a blind eye to hostility towards Catholics, "he said.

 

"Tygodnik Solidarnosc" is the first free magazine in Poland. Just before the European Parliament elections, its fanpage coverage dropped 90 percent.” admitted Cezary Krysztopa.

Varro Vooglaid from Estonia also took the floor.

 

"In Estonia, YouTube is removing recordings expressing opposition to the LGBT ideology. Some recordings have been removed without any explanation.” he claimed.

 

 

 

 

 


DATA: 2019-09-20 13:27
 
 
Share:  
 
 
 
drukuj
 
 
 
GOOD TEXT
0
 
 
 
Comment on the article
Nick *:
Your opinion *:
wyślij opinie
Regulations
Click to read

1. It is forbidden to publish comments on the forum that:
- promote deviant behavior, contrary to the natural law;
- offend the Catholic faith and the Catholic Church;
- contain obscenity (pursuant to Art. 3 of the Act of 7 October 1999 On the Polish Language);
- contain information burdening other persons with accusations which have not been proven (Art. 23 of the Civil Code);
- lead to copyright infringement (Act of 4 February 1994 On Copyright and Related Rights);
- contain links to and addresses of other websites, personal details, contact information or e-mail addresses;
- are advertisements or spam (have no relation to the commented article);
- are direct, brutal attacks on interlocutors or call for aggression against them;
- are inappropriate in the context of information about the death of a public or private person;
- contain remarks addressed to the editorial team of PCh24.pl (we really appreciate them but we ask for e-mail contact as only then we can assure that they will be delivered to the persons responsible for the service content).

 

2. All comments contravening item one of the present Rules will be removed by the moderator.

 


 

Copyright 2019 by
STOWARZYSZENIA KULTURY CHRZEŚCIJAŃSKIEJ
M. KS. PIOTRA SKARGI

 

No materials published by www.pch.24.pl may be copied, distributed, redistributed or exploited in any form, including posting on the Internet, without the consent of Fundacja Instytutu Edukacji Społecznej i Religijnej im. Ks. Piotra Skargi located in Kraków (Publisher). Any use or exploitation of any material in whole or in part violating the law, i.e. without the permission of the Publisher is prohibited under penalty and may be prosecuted.


Requests should be directed to the editorial staff of the website at: [email protected] Permission is granted in written or electronic form.


The content of this website, after obtaining permission, maybe distributed so long as directly under the published material the information about its source (PCh24.pl) and a link to the source page (a link with the attribute rel=”follow”) are included. Permission does not include any illustrations related to texts. This clause does not apply to these users of this website who link any material published on a website in social media.